The Set Up

The Set Up

Status: Finished

Genre: Erotica

Details

Status: Finished

Genre: Erotica

Summary

Lily spends lots of time with her three gay friends Hanson, Reece and Chris. But suddenly a night of truth or dare turns into a horrible realization. Maybe her gay friends aren't all that gay after all. And tonight Lily is the only girl in sight. And she has this silly feeling that she's been set up.

Summary

Lily spends lots of time with her three gay friends Hanson, Reece and Chris. But suddenly a night of truth or dare turns into a horrible realization.
Maybe her gay friends aren't all that gay after all. And tonight Lily is the only girl in sight.
And she has this silly feeling that she's been set up.

Content

Submitted: July 16, 2012

A A A | A A A

Content

Submitted: July 16, 2012

A A A

A A A


It wasn’t unusual to spend the night with Chris, Hanson and Reece, my three gay friends, and my three best friends. I was the only girl of the group, but still, it wasn’t all that unusual since we’d been friends for so long now.

It was at Hanson’s house tonight, and I knocked on the door, my sleeping bag tucked under my arm and my change of clothes in a bag on my shoulder. To my surprise, all three of them answered the door. Usually I was at Hanson’s before Chris and Reece.

Hanson winked at me. “Come on in sweetheart. It’s gonna be a fun night.”

So I came in, and we all started in on how hot Channing Tatum was and what colors brought out our eyes. We all sat in the livingroom, then I noticed Chris give Hanson a meaningful look. Hanson looked back at him, then at Reece.

Reece just smiled. Was I missing something?

“Let’s play Truth or Dare.” Hanson suggested. He combed a hand through his black hair. He bit at his lip a little before looking at me with those secretive blue eyes of his.

I nodded, still a little confused. “Okay then.”

“So Lily,” Chris looked at me, and he was a dirty blonde, with green-brown eyes. And he too was hiding something. “Truth or dare?”

“Truth.” I answered quickly.

“Are you still a virgin?” he asked.

I blushed, then nodded. “Yeah.”

He just gave me a reassuring smile. “Okay your turn.”

“Okay, Reece, truth or dare?” I asked him.

Reece was laying back on his forearms, his legs stretched out and crossed. “Dare.” He answered boldly. He was built, but so were Chris and Hanson, and it wasn’t too surprising considering that they worked out together. All three had rippling muscles and toned stomachs. Reece had auburn hair, and he was really hot with those smoky green eyes of his.

“Hm,” I was thoughtful. “Try to do a backflip.”

He rolled his eyes and stood up, and easily jumped and did a backflip. “There.” He muttered, sounding bored. “My turn now?”

“Yep.” Hanson muttered.

His eyes shot over to Chris. “Truth or dare?”

“Dare.” Chris said, which was unusual for him. He usually played it pretty safe in this game.

“Kiss Lily.”

Though I was surprised, Chris didn’t seem to be. He smirked, then leaned towards me, and pressed his lips to mine, making my heart race. Hanson and Reece watched with a lot of interest as Chris, who was very much gay, kissed me, and seemed to be enjoying it. He even eased his tongue into my mouth.

He pulled away after another few seconds. “Well, I believe it’s my turn now.” He said huskily.

“Hanson-“

“Dare.” He said quickly.

“Take off Lily’s clothes, all of them.”

It was a ridiculous thought, I told myself, but I couldn’t shake the feeling that I was being set up.

Hanson moved toward me, and I felt my heart race as he smirked at me. By this point usually the guys were making out with each other and I was practically out of the game. Suddenly I was getting a lot of attention.

Hanson started unbuttoning my shirt, then slid it off my shoulders so I was just in my bra. He reached behind me, and easily unclipped it and pulled it off so I was half naked. He threw the bra across the room and I felt heat and a bit of fear surge through me as they all stared at my chest.

“Lay down so I can get your pants off.” Hanson told me.

So I laid down, and he grabbed the top of my sweatpants and slowly untied them, then slid them down my legs. He tossed them aside, then greedily went after my panties, quickly pulling them off, then, throwing those too.

He moved back, and they just stared at me, taking it all in. “Reece,” Hanson said after a few moments. “Truth or Dare?”

“Dare.” Reece replied quietly.

Hanson grinned. “Finger Lily.”

I gasped and crossed my legs in response. “No!” I said quickly.

Reece moved towards me, then to my complete shock and horror he jerked my legs apart, and shoved in his middle finger straight into my pussy. I couldn’t believe what had come over my three best friends. He moved it in and out for a moment, his eyes on mine.

Chris and Hanson moved towards me, and suddenly Hanson’s mouth was on mine and Chris’ mouth was on my left breast. Reece added another finger in my pussy. Then he stopped abruptly. “I never thought I’d say this, but I want her. I want inside.” He breathed, his hands tackling for the zipper on his pants.

Hanson pulled away and looked at him. “She a virgin, so just be gentle.”

“Okay, at first.” Reece agreed.

I was far too shocked to try to say anything. But when Reece had taken off his pants I jerked my face away from Hanson and screamed. “Please don’t do this! Please! I’m your best friend! Don’t make me do this!”

“Lily,” Hanson murmured. “Don’t you remember the deal? We made it three years ago today. If you were still a virgin in three years, you said your virginity was ours.”

I did remember, but at that time I had never thought they’d take me up on it. At that time they said girls were disgusting to them. Still, I never broke a deal. “I’m scared.” I whispered, tears beginning to stream down my face.

“Hey,” Chris whispered, wrapping his arms around me and hugging me. “We’re not going to hurt you Lily. We’ve all taken care of you and we will tonight.”

“You guys don’t like girls.” I breathed.

“Lily, you’re different. We were talking about it a few weeks ago. Yeah, most girls don’t affect us, but you’re different. It just takes one look at you and we want you. Remember when we got into a fight and we told you it was some jerks who were teasing us about being gay?” Chris reminded.

I nodded slowly. “Yes, I remember.”

Reece continued. “We got into a fight with each other, over you. When we realized we all wanted you, none of us wanted to share. But we came to an agreement. Either we shared you or none of us got you. So here we are. Don’t worry Lily, we’re going to take care of you.”

“So just lay back and relax.” Hanson said and smiled. “And Lily, I’m afraid this isn’t going to be a onetime thing. We’ve already agreed to trade you off. One night with me, one with Chris, one with Reece. Then you get a break for a day, then we start over.”

“What if I don’t want to.” I breathed.

Chris started to speak, but Reece cut in. “We’re not going to talk about this now. Right now we have a deal, one that was your idea Lily, and we all know you won’t back out. So we’ll do this first, and talk about the rest later.

I closed my eyes and exhaled deeply. “Hanson, you go first, I can’t be gentle. I’ll end up hurting her.” Reece muttered in annoyance with himself.

He and Hanson switched places, and Reece took my mouth roughly and Chris’ mouth went back to my breast, his hand massaging the right one as he sucked on the left.

Despite my fear and confusion, I felt myself getting wet. Hanson was soon naked, his body rippling in muscles and my heart thumped unevenly as I took in his size. Anticipating my reaction, Reece and Chris each grabbed a leg and pulled them apart. They continued kissing me and running their free hands over my body. Reece’s lips were on my neck now and Chris was on my mouth. Hanson’s face moved down to my pussy.

I gasped as his tongue darted out and touched my clit. I could feel Reece grin against my skin and Chris moved his tongue into my mouth to tangle with my own. Hanson’s tongue twisted and circled my clit, and I started breathing roughly as Reece’s mouth moved down to my right breast and Chris went back to my left. They both started to suck, gently biting, and Hanson slid his tongue up and down my entrance, making me shudder.

When Hanson moved away, Chris and Reece slid their hands under my legs, and pulled them up and farther apart. Each took one arm and held them over my head as Hanson positioned himself over me. He kissed me first, then lowered his hips so I could feel the head of his cock rub against the lips of my pussy.

Slowly, he moved his hips forward and began to push in. When I jerked Chris and Reece tightened their grips on my hands and legs. I felt the hot meat enter and started panting from the pain of it. Hanson kept moving in and I felt my walls trying to resist against being opened and pushed past their usual limits.

When he was completely in, he stayed there for a moment, watching the tears streak down my face as I continued to drag in breaths like some kind of injured animal. He pulled out, and pushed back in, then began moving rhythmically. It felt so damn good, I could barely stand it.

Hanson thrust in harder, and I let out a cry of ecstasy. Reece’s hands tightened on me as if in impatience. Hanson’s lips crushed down on mine as he began to take me with an animal like passion. I felt myself tighten as he drove into me. “I’m going to…” I screamed.

I came hard, and Hanson let out a groan and came inside of me. He nearly collapsed on top of me, but caught himself. We stayed there, like that for what was only minutes but felt like hours.

*****

They had kept their promise, they had bathed me, massaged me, then dressed me in a warm robe. We sat in Hanson’s room now, and the boys all watched me cautiously. “Tomorrow you’ll come to my house.” Reece explained to me. “Then I’ll give you to Chris,” he said it with some irritation. “Then you’ll come back here.”

“What if that isn’t what I want?” I whispered.

“Lily, it’s what’s best, for us all to stay together.” Hanson explained. I was sitting between his legs, and he had me wrapped tightly in his arms.

“I’m not only a human being, but your best friend. How can you treat me like I’m just some kind of sex slave?”

“Lily, we’re not just gonna pass you around like some kind of fuck buddy. It’s an arrangement, and you’ll be treated like a princess. You’ll get more than you’ve ever had. We’ve talked about this and talked about this, and it’s the best way.” Chris explained.

“It’s just the way it has to be.” Reece told me.

“Let’s get some sleep for now.” Hanson said. “Reece will be taking you with him in the morning.”

As we all got ready to sleep, I wasn’t sure what to think. I loved all three of them, but this just didn’t make sense. I was between Reece and Hanson on the bed, And Chris was on the other side of Reece. I closed my eyes and tried to pretend like everything was okay, that I could do this. It didn’t seem like I had much of a choice anyway.

End.


© Copyright 2018 TheAnimal. All rights reserved.

Add Your Comments:

Comments

avatar

Anonymous

avatar

Author
Reply

avatar

Anonymous

avatar

Author
Reply

avatar

Author
Reply

avatar

Anonymous

avatar

Author
Reply

avatar

Anonymous

avatar

Author
Reply

avatar

Author
Reply

avatar

Anonymous

avatar

Author
Reply

avatar

Anonymous

avatar

Author
Reply

avatar

Anonymous

avatar

Author
Reply

avatar

Anonymous

avatar

Author
Reply

avatar

Author
Reply

avatar

Anonymous

avatar

Author
Reply

avatar

Anonymous

avatar

Author
Reply

avatar

Author
Reply

avatar

Author
Reply

avatar

Author
Reply

Other Content by TheAnimal

More Great Reading

Popular Tags