Why not Have Two?

Why not Have Two?

Status: Finished

Genre: Erotica

Details

Status: Finished

Genre: Erotica

Summary

Sarah spends the day at her best friend Ally's house alone after she goes out to rent DVDs or is she really all alone?

Summary

Sarah spends the day at her best friend Ally's house alone after she goes out to rent DVDs or is she really all alone?

Content

Submitted: March 11, 2012

A A A | A A A

Content

Submitted: March 11, 2012

A A A

A A A


This story was inspired by one of my fans on booksie check her out-jennetjanare. It was actually a fantasy of hers that she suggested I write so just let me know if you like it then you can compliment her for such a brilliant idea!




Isn’t life great? I mean, when you realize you’re living every girls naughty fantasy; life has to be frickin’ great! I guess that’s why my life is so great!

“You can’t have her, I’ve always loved her and now you just want to walk right up and take her away, I won’t have that,” said Joshua to his older brother.

Although they looked almost identical, Joshua was the one who wore glasses, his smooth, pale skin was blemished in freckles which he hated but I adored them. They speckled from just above his brow, a few below his right eye and a single one at the left of his mouth. He had big saddle brown eyes which lit up whenever I was around- and I loved that. Crazy long eyelashes hid them when he held his head low. His lips were plump, pink and always made me wonder what they tasted like whenever I went over to visit my best friend Ally.

I had known Ally for years and I also knew her brothers Joshua and James but I had never talked to them before, maybe I had wanted to but I just never had the confidence to. Both of them were cute, James was the elder and was taller than Joshua so he always had this unapproachable air to him- besides the fact that he was always grumpy and hardly came out his room when I was there.

James had the same saddle brown eyes, but shaggy, dark brown hair as opposed to Joshua’s dirty blonde. He didn’t have freckles but had those same plump lips which were always pouty and added to their plumpness. He was like that guy you would fuck on the first date.

“So what do you wanna do now you’re here,” asked Ally as she sat up further on the bed next to me.

“Uhmmm, I’m not sure,” I replied. Since we had spent all our days together playing, laughing, talking…it was hard finding something to do during autumn. Outside was wet and slippery and since it was still a little chilly, hardly anyone went outside.

“I could go and rent some DVDs from the store if you don’t mind,” she asked, getting up from the bed excited about her brilliant plan.

“Yeah! That sounds like a good idea and I’ll get some food and drinks ready for us by the time you get back,” I said, sliding off the bed.

I watched as Ally put on her long, ankle length, blue jeans, covering her legs which were exposed before in her short pants. Then she slipped on her red and white sweater over the pink cotton shirt she was wearing before. She tied her hair up in a messy bun at the top of her head, pulling her curly dirty blonde hair with darker streaks of brown from her face, revealing her beautiful green eyes which I adored. Just like Joshua she had freckles which made her cute button nose pop from her face, but her lips were thin and seemed to be as if someone had forgotten she needed lips and just cut a hole for her to speak- I thought it made her look more sophisticated but she didn’t like them at all.

“Okay I’m done so I’ll be back in like an hour since it takes so long to choose movies,” she said as she picked up her small black bag and went out of her bedroom.

I decided I would pop some popcorn for the first few movies then we would eat my famous lasagna with fruit punch smoothies, laced with Verdi- Ally had always liked that part. I went into the kitchen which was downstairs, around the corner and hidden by a big wall which served as a divider for the kitchen and living room with an arched entry way. Since I was by Ally I felt there was no need to wear much clothes- James was always in his room and Joshua treated me more like a little sister than anything else. So I gave my short pants one final tug then tied up my long black hair and began to cook the lasagna. I went to the sink to fill the large, stainless steel pot with water to get that on the fire first since it would take the longest time. Besides the water hitting the bottom of the pan the house was relatively quiet, until I heard muffled voices coming from upstairs. The only two they could be were Joshua and James, but why were they quarreling and it seemed so heated. I turned the faucet and shut off the water almost simultaneously the noise stopped, but I was really curious as to what made them so angry. Anyways I just continued going about my task oblivious to everyone around me, then I heard someone coming downstairs. I couldn’t see who it was yet so I turned my direction to the entry way and waited. It was James. For the first time since I’ve known Ally, I saw him outside of his room. He walked in, running his fingers through his hair. His well-toned abs exposed since he was just in a boxers and I stood there, pot in hand staring at his beauty.

I couldn’t take my eyes off of him until our eyes met and I felt a little uncomfortable so I turned and put the pot on the stove, all the while I could feel his presence behind me as he went to the sink, presumably for some water. I turned on the stove and watched the flames flicker on in a dazzling blue, orange and yellow light, which distracted me from noticing him moving across to me.

? ? ? ? ? ? ?

Oh it’s Ally’s friend Sarah,” I said silently as I walked into the kitchen, thirsty from all that quarreling with Joshua. He’s such a prick; I can’t believe he would think I would just let him have her. She’s so beautiful! Look at her legs and her ass just jiggling in her short pants. I definitely want some of that- and I don’t mean what she cooking either. ‘Jeez, I can’t hold back and longer,” I thought to myself when I realized my dick wouldn’t stay down. I swear he has a mind of his own. But right now we’re thinking the same thing…I need to fuck her…

? ? ? ? ?? ? ? ?

I realized James was closer to me than I thought when I felt his breath on the back of my neck. It was cool and made me shiver. I felt his arms around my waist then he gripped me tighter and pulled me back onto him. I jerked forward when I felt his erect cock between my cheeks but there was no where I could go. He leaned in, burrying his head in the nape of my neck, then I felt his lips brush against the nape of my neck slowly. I tried to utter the words stop, but his grip was too strong and his lips were touching me perfectly. Then he raised the other hand to my cheek and stroked it gently,

“I love you,” he whispered. His voice resonated inside me making it even harder to resist. But then it hit me, ‘he loves me,’ since when?

“I love you,” he whispered again this time he guided my lips to his, stopping me from questioning his actions. Every time I tried to struggle he gripped my wrist tighter and pulled me closer to him, deepening the kiss. I felt his hand travel slowly up my thighs then settle on my pussy. It felt so good when I felt him there, when he began to rub slowly. I eventually forgot that I had never spoken to him before, all I wanted was him.

James broke the kiss long enough to take off his clothes, he turned me to face him, then smiled. He lifted my shirt up and over my head, revealing my uncupped breasts since I hardly ever wore bras. His eyes seemed to light up when he saw them, they hung from my body but were still firm. He leaned in to kiss them but pulled back just when I felt his breath on my skin. Raising his hands lingeringly over my thighs he reached for the waist of my shorts and slid it down effortlessly, revealing my pink and purple lace French cut. He smiled again then lowered his head slowly… “What was he going to do,” I thought, as he gripped my hips firmly, preventing me from moving.

“I can’t wait to taste you,” he said, as if confirming my suspicions or more like my fantasy.

“N-nn—oo,” I stuttered, as James’ tongue pressed against my clit, the thin layer of cloth the only thing stopping direct contact.

He flashed me this seductive smile infused with a sinister look which made me so wet. He knew what he was doing- he was good. James lowered his hands from my hips then slid off my panty easily. As soon as it was off, he crushed his lips against mine. Working his tongue skillfully over my clit, I moaned loudly when I felt his tongue slide in and out of me. He raised his hands to my hips again to force his tongue deeper inside my pussy.

“James…James, ughhhh, James,” I screamed his name uncontrollably and when he realized he had me weak-kneed and begging he lifted his head. Looking me straight in the eyes then he smiled at me again and grabbed my hips and spun me around so my hands were on the counter.

“James do—nnn’ttt,” I tried again but it was all in vain. I felt his hard cock push into me and James grabbed my hips again and forced me down so my legs sprawled open, inviting him deeper.

“Ughhh Sarah…you just feel so fucking good,” he said, as he entered me. His wet head slid inside and I could feel my walls contracting around it making it harder for me to protest when my body wanted it so badly.

He began to thrust hard inside me, shaking the counter with short, firm jabs. Then he brought his hands from my hips and cupped my breasts, he played with the nipples, then squeezed them hard until I felt a little pain and I moaned loud.

“Ughhhh James, James,” escaped my lips.

“Yes, I know you wanted this ever since and I’m gonna give you what you and I want,” he said then he thrusted harder.

I felt him sliding in and out of me until James was pumping harder and harder quickening the pace with every thrust and I was loving it; I held my head between my shoulders and took him inside me bravely it felt so damn good, his big hard cock pulsating inside of me, met by his strong jabs and the clapping of his balls. I wanted to cum so badly, “ughh James, please let me cum,” I pleaded.

But before we could even reach our climax Joshua walked in, his eyes widened from what he saw. I stood there, fully naked, my breasts hung from my body as his brother’s stiff cock was still inside me.

“Something you want Joshua,” asked James as he began to pump inside me slower.

I really felt shameful as I watched Joshua stand there infuriated while his brother fucked me nice and slow and the thing is- I couldn’t help but enjoy the feeling and moan ever so often as Joshua just watched. I opened my eyes again to get a glimpse of him and I realized the protrusion of his hard cock in his pants. “Was he turned on by this,” I thought as James grabbed my hips again, continuing to pump slowly. “Gosh this feels so good,” I said out loud, not realizing.

“Yeah I know answered James,” as he ran his lips down my back lightly.

I turned to Joshua who pushed his glasses further up his nose and began to place his hand at the front of his pants and he started to rub slowly.

“You know you want to,” said James, urging Joshua to do something which I had no idea what it was but then I saw Joshua walk slowly towards us, he dropped his pants revealing his erect dick since he wasn’t wearing underwear and began to stroke it. He rocked back his head and closed his eyes for a brief moment then he walked behind James, then he whispered something to him and they both shot me a seductive smile that made me so wet just thinking about what they were going to do.

I felt James quicken the pace then he pulled me from the counter, still thrusting inside me then Joshua walked around to my face and held his cock right by my lips. Teasing to put it in but just brushing against my soft, wet lips. I had no protests to this and I opened my mouth and took it in. It was warm and pulsed when I sucked on it. I tried my best to run my tongue over it, flicking it about in my mouth and Joshua moaned when I sucked his head harder while James began to fuck me harder from the back.

“Suck it Sarah, you lil’ slut. You know you want to,” said James as he began to speed up the pace. His balls madly knocking against my clit which enhanced both of our pleasure and he leaned his head back and closed his eyes.

“She’s not a slut,” called Joshua as I sucked his dick hard, he grabbed my head then ran his fingers through my hair and closed his eyes too. “Yeah you’re right, she’s the woman that both of us love,” James said in a surprisingly serious tone which caught me off guard a little. I bobbed my head to the pace James set and they both fucked me from the back and front and honestly- I was enjoying it.

“Ughhh Saraaahh,” Joshua called, as I applied pressure to his head with my teeth then I used my lips and sucked hard on it and without notice I pressed my tongue onto the open area almost as if I was trying to bore a hole.

“Ohhhhh Sarah, please don’t stop, please ughhh Sarah this feels so good,” he called from above me as he began to pump his dick in my mouth, forcing it deeper down my throat and I gladly accepted it.

“Ughhh Sarah ughhh I’m fucking cumming,” I heard James from behind me as he thrusted so hard my legs got weak but I kept my balance long enough to reach my climax. James lifted my legs slightly off the ground and I bounced on this dick while he guided me back to the counter and Joshua sat on top of it and finished pump into my mouth until I felt his cum on my face- it was so warm an sticky and the bit that came in my mouth tasted good.

“Ughh Sarah, I want you to cum on this dick,” shouted James while his brother went around him and bent down and began to lick my clit.

It felt so fucking good to have two hot brothers.

Joshua sucked and sucked hard, running his tongue over the sensitive area and James thrusted causing me to reach my climax.

“I’m cumming James, I’m fucking cumming,” I shouted while Joshua sucked me.

“Uhh shit Sarah, uugghhh yeah cum all over this dick, ugghhhh baby I’m cumming,” he shouted too, until I felt James ejaculate inside me and fill me with his warm cum, it felt so great.

James let me down easily but I looked down at Joshua whose cock was still hard. Then I dropped to the floor a little exhausted from the both of them and I closed my eyes for a little only to open them to a sharp pain in my head.

Joshua pulled my lock of my long black hair to get my attention.

“I’ve always wanted to do that,” he said, his cute smile even cuter from his glasses.

He pulled again, this time dragging me to my feet and I collapsed in his arms.

“You’re such a princess,” he said, as he lifted me over the threshold and took me to his room where James was naked just as hard as him.

Joshua threw me down onto the bed, somewhat rough but I could tell he didn’t want to hurt me then he pulled me by my hair to the edge of the bed. I loved being man-handled it felt so good feeling a man treat you on the same level as them; it’s like saying I don’t think you’re a pathetic weak being that can’t take pain, and watching Joshua dominate me like this, his glasses still on was damn sexy.

He pulled me by my hair again and flipped me over so I lay on my back and leaned in gently, “you know I love you right,” he said, his voice soft and gentle, while James watched from the computer chair a few centimeters away. “You know I wanna make love to you eventually,” he continued. I shook my head to let him know I understood him because a part of me wanted to be romantically involved with him- like he seemed so loving, caring gentle.

He nipped my ear softly then whispered, “but I’m not gonna make love to you now… right now…I just want to fuck you so hard,” he finished, which surprised me and I smiled inwardly as Joshua showed me a more rough side of him.

“You love me,” I asked.

“Yes I do, so much,” he replied.

“Then there’s something I want you do for me,” I said.

“What, what is it,” he asked, as he lifted his head and listened attentively.

I raised my head to his ear, “I want you to kiss your brother.”

He paused for a moment, I could feel his breathing quicken but despite them being brothers I just got this feeling that there was always something more to the relationship.

I watched as Joshua got up and walked slowly to James, stroking his dick while he walked- and since James didn’t know what was going on it made it all the more interesting.

Joshua leaned on his brother, then placed his hand on the nape of his neck and pressed his lips against James’. I heard their muffled moans as James pulled Joshua down on his naked hard cock and I watched as Joshua bounced up and down on it lightly. It looked so fucking sexy. James grabbed his brother’s neck and kissed him on the lips, long and lingering. He started with his eyes clothes then he opened them and looked directly at me while Joshua was backing me. James never took his eyes off of me as I began to rub my clit up and down just watching them go at it with each other. They started moaning again as Joshua wrapped his arms around his brother and held onto him, his legs sprawled wildly over him as the erect cocks meet in the middle, then James lowered his hand, while looking at me and began to stroke both their cocks at the same time. He pumped them both in his hand as they pulsed against each other then I called out to Joshua, “you can come now.”

He broke the kiss slowly; lingering around his brother’s lips as I watched them part, then James got up and led Joshua over to me. Joshua bent his one of his knees onto the bed and propped himself up with his hands, then James came from around him and dragged me up by my hair, then whisper, “I love kissing my little brother…almost as much as I love kiss you,” then he kissed me passionately while Joshua looked on. I felt the grip loosen around my hair and my head fell back onto the bed and Joshua climbed on top me. Lowering himself until his head met my entrance and he teased me by rubbing his pre-cum soaked head on my lips.

I really wanted it now, I couldn’t wait.

“Please Joshua put it in,” I said, my eyes closed in anticipation.

“No,” he said sternly, sliding it up and down outside my wet entrance.

“Please, please, please put it in,” I begged some more.

“No,” he said, just like the same way he did before.

“Beg some more,” he exclaimed.

I opened my eyes and grabbed his hips,” please fuck me Joshua, please,” and I pleaded with my eyes and he gave because I felt his firm thrust against my walls and I was elated.

He pumped slowly, filling me with himself first then he picked up the pace and began to thrust faster and harder, racking my body with pain but it felt so good I loved it.

“James come!” I heard him call to James who was watching us.

He ran his fingers through his hair then forced Joshua further up the bed, causing a deeper penetration and I moaned so loudly.

“Oh she likes that,” said Joshua as he looked back at his brother who was now between my legs.

Joshua leaned against my chest, I could feel his heart beat against mine, but then I felt something else enter me.

James began to nudge at my ass hole with his dick. I could feel him teasing it as Joshua was fucking me, then he lowered himself more and forced in. I screamed out in pain as he showed no mercy and grabbed my hips while leaning against his brother’s back.

“Yes fuck her James,” Joshua said as he too thrusted.

“I will, I’ll fuck her so hard,” he said while Joshua smiled at me. Their weight was surprisingly not that much as I assumed they tried not to burden me with that but James just kept thrusting in that tight hole- it felt good being fucked in two holes again.

“Ughhh Sarah, Ughhh Sarah,” Joshua called as he leaned against me and thrusted.

“Ohh Joshua she feels so good from behind her and you look so sexy,” said James as he kissed his brother’s back.

“Don—‘tt” said Joshua as he shuddered when James touched him.

“What, you know we always do this anyway,” said James and I felt him pull out of me and thrust into Joshua as I felt his balls rub against my leg and bang against my body along with Joshua’s. He was fucking his own brother!

“Ughhh Sarah, I can’t hold out…out… any longer,” called Joshua as he thrusted inside me and his brother fucked him from the back, “ohh James, I ca—nnn’tt,” he said.

“Oh yes…you…can,” James replied with a loud grunt and thrusted harder inside Joshua until I felt my walls tighten and my climax was nearing. But before I could cum, James thrust back inside my ass hard, trying to please himself as well, as he shifted between his brother and me then he stopped at me and thrust until I felt him go harder and harder and Joshua moaned on top me.

“Uhghhh Sarahhh I’m gonna cum,” said James as he grabbed his brothers hips and thrusted inside me.

“Ughhh cum James, cum inside her with me,” said Joshua as he thrusted in time with his brother then sucked on my nipples hard.

He rolled his tongue over them, then kissed me until I felt both their cum inside me at the same time- it was so fucking awesome!!

“Ughhh James, Joshua…. I’m cumming too, don’t pull out, please don’t pull out,” I said and both of them obeyed and kept thrusting.

“We won’t pull out if that’s what you want,” James said, showing a soft hearted side to him and he leaned in and whispered to Joshua then kissed him on the cheek.

They grunted as they moved inside me for the last time and I screamed their names uncontrollably as I came on Joshua’s dick and felt James’ balls on me. It felt so good.

James pulled out slowly then fell onto the bed while Joshua stayed on top me, his dick still inside, pulsing- I loved that.

“Hey, you’re stealing all the good parts,” said James as he looked on jealous.

Joshua stuck out his tongue at him then smiled and James got up and kissed me upside down, leaving me breathless while Joshua looked on longingly…

“I want one too,” he said, in the cutest voice I have ever heard.

“No,” said James sternly.

“All for Sarah,” he said, then he leaned over and kissed me again so passionately I was overwhelmed.

“I love you Sarah,” he whispered, as his lips trailed mine softly now.

Then Joshua pulled out slowly and curled up next to me, “ I love you too,” he whispered then kissed me in my neck….

I must admit…I’m a very lucky girl!!


© Copyright 2018 payton2. All rights reserved.

Add Your Comments:

Comments

avatar

Author
Reply

avatar

Author
Reply

avatar

Author
Reply

avatar

Author
Reply

avatar

Author
Reply

avatar

Author
Reply

avatar

Anonymous

avatar

Author
Reply

avatar

Author
Reply

avatar

Author
Reply

avatar

Anonymous

avatar

Author
Reply

avatar

Author
Reply

avatar

Author
Reply

avatar

Author
Reply

avatar

Author
Reply

avatar

Author
Reply

Other Content by payton2

More Great Reading

Popular Tags